Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Brooke White goes home


OK - back to the results.

Syesha and Brooke are back on the stage ... And after more than 45 million votes, it is Brooke White who goes home. Syesha is safe another week.

I almost feel bad for Brooke -- she's hysterical crying, almost immediately. It was her time to go, though. She actually got a lot further than I thought she would at the beginning of the season. I can't believe they're making her sing when she can't stop crying. Not nice at all. Well, only three weeks to go ... Can't wait to see who takes the prize.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Syesha and David Cook in the bottom two next week with Syesha going home. David Cook goes home the following week because a rocker will never win American Idol.

It will come down to David A. and Jason. The winner will be whoever the teen girls vote more for because I've always said thet they are the ones who vote the most.

My guess is Jason will be the next Idol because the teen girls love his looks. So singing is not what this show is about..
The only way to ever make this show fair would be to limit one vote per telephone number or it will never be the best who wins the show

Anonymous said...

YAY!!!!!
Finally!!!!!

Enough with the drama, Brooke! Grow up!

Let's get on to it: a JC/DC final

The American Idol execs did not get their way -- good!!! Ha Ha

This IS a popularity contest as it SHOULD be -- we listeners BUY the music and vote for our favorites.

Anonymous said...

I want David Cook to leave. He has no personality and just bugs me. I'm suprised Jason's come so far; I never liked him. David A's gonna win.. I just hope the media doesn't make him into the next Aaron Carter.

Anonymous said...

This is definatly a popularity contest and dredlocks is going to win because the girls think he is so cute. Can't sing worth a dam. So I guess american idol will get 50% of nothing because I woulnt spend money on his music. The really good singers leave the show.

FAITHFULLSHARON said...

america is deaf and that is all I have to say! the last 2 weeks sorry to say but nice eyed Jason should have got the boot off the show. Brooke is way better than he is! And the other girl Syesha shouldn't have been with her either in the bottom two. sorry David but you stunk last night! wake up people it is almost the end here!!

Anonymous said...

Finally Brooke is gone........I couldnt take her crying or that thing she does w/ her mouth anymore!! David Cook needs to go as well. This guy just seems to love himself. Michael Johns should of been the winner.

Anonymous said...

i think its going to be a "battle of the Davids" for this years winner.
I like Syesha, great voice and she can easily do broadway.
Jason C is giving up. seems he can't do anything beyond that mello type beat.

Anonymous said...

I also forsee the two Davids being the final people left. Brooke deserved to go home this week and I think Jason should be next, but Syesha has been at the bottom very consistently. Syesha sings much nicer than Jason. I don't think Jason could hit a high note if he tried. David C should win as he's the "total" package. David A can sing, but I think that's it and with ballads mostly - he's not very good with upbeat songs.

Anonymous said...

I think David Awfuletta should go BYE BYE!
Boring Boring Boring!
The Bomb Ranndy said?
I think he BOMBED for the past 3-4 weeks the only worthwhile performance he had was beatles week when he did Imagine after that it's the same old dull boring non talented performances.
DAVID COOK should take it all he is original and makes each song his own. Brooke "CRY BABY" White good riddens already! Jason Castro other than nice eyes he's gotta go next! Syesha has a nice voice but nothing special. If anyone but DC wins it is a travisty.

Anonymous said...

For all the claiming of this being the most talented bunch ever, they are hardly that. They seem to be pleading for that great performance and it just isn't happening.

Anonymous said...

This years show is not the best at all. Jason, I do not like period and those dread locks, geez!No voice either. David A. is good but too shy and David C. knows his music and what he can do. He has the confidence! Syesha has a voice and can sing but give me a break. It's a man's year on the show.

This show should be about voices not looks!

Anonymous said...

I just wish they would let these kids sing whatever they'd like and maybe we could hear just how good some of them are. Andrew Lloyd Webber? Neil Diamond? Give me a break! Do you ever hear a pop singer singing this old crap? I never like Neil Diamond when I was young.

Anonymous said...

Good Bye, Cry baby!

Anonymous said...

OMG I cant believe they sent Brooke home Jason cant carry a tune in a bucket... well it is the Fantasia season all over again, she sounds like a cartoon character and she still one. Oh well popularity counts for something I suppose.

Anonymous said...

Say goodbye to David Cook tonight even thou Jason Castro screwed up!!

Anonymous said...

Brooke was fantastic in the start. I feel like she has great potential, and while she sorta started to fall apart a bit towards the end, I still think she'll go far.