Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Carly Smithson goes home


Ryan says to Randy that he looks surprised. Randy says he is shocked, that it must be a bit of a popularity week in the vote because these two sang really good last night. Paula agrees, saying she has never seen such relaxation and joy at this stage in the competition.

So, after 38 million votes, Carly is the next to go home. Wow!!!! I can't say I'm upset, but WOW!!! I'm kind of surprised - I thought the day would never come.

14 comments:

Bill said...

Carly has more talent in her little thumb than a pack of Jason's...sorry, but she didn't deserve this. Jason Castro isn't bad, but his performance in the Andrew Lloyd Webber competition was awful.

Mike said...

The wrong person leaves again. Jason your a terrable singer. The only reason your still in is that the girls like your locks. I will not watch this show again.

Anonymous said...

I have completely had it with this show. The bottom 2 should have been Jason and Brooke.I'm done watching.

Anonymous said...

Carly and her screaming, her self-infatuation, and her disgusting tattoos are FINALLY gone!!

Perhaps her next recording contract won't be as much of a disaster as her first one.

Anonymous said...

I can't believe how dumb this show's getting! omg, Jason and Brooke is STILL IN? man, this show's getting more weird each week! I feel that america's got it totally wrong. Jason and Brooke should be ON THE BOTTOM and OUT! I can't stand looking at them sitting in the "safe" row... it disgusts me! I loved Syesha's performance and she didn't deserve to be on the bottom at all!!! I think, America's people is on crack.

Anonymous said...

Jason with dreadlocks and talks like a dope head should NOT be safe! what the hell is he on the "safe" side??? and Brooke... the pouty queen of all, i'm sorry, but she's always pouting on stage and that makes me sick. Nothing positive about her. I don't know what the hell these 2 people are doing on the safe seats... But, next week, one of them should be out anyways... sorry to see carly go... she was alright.

Anonymous said...

KEEP WATCHING THE SHOW PEOPLE COS THE WORST OF ALL: JASON AND BROOKE IS BOUND TO LEAVE AND THAT WILL BE WHAT I'M WAITING FOR. MY HATS IS OFF TO DAVID COOK AND DAVID ARCHULETA... YOU GUYS ROCK!!

Anonymous said...

I know you are a Jason fan, but he or Brooke should've gone home.

I'm not a Carly fan, and I can live without her and her tatooed entourage, but this elimination was buffalo chips.

Jason reminds me of Rolf the Muppet. His limited vocal range has carried him as far as he can go on this show. Enough already.

coolbamf said...

It's called the Jesus effect... America HATES when someone questions or talks bad about Jesus... and Jesus Christ Superstar is about Jesus "actually believing he's God" BAD SONG CHOICE... just like singing Proud to be an American. Song choice is EVERYTHING... Jason Castro sang a song everyone knows... Brook stayed because she's honest... and picks honest songs... I knew Carly was gone as soon as the words Jesus Christ Superstar slipped out of her lips.

Jennifer said...

you are a very pessimistic person. I read all your posts and it just leaves me hating everything. Since this is your job, you would think you would put a little more effort. You dont have to like everything just be more positive. You should seriously just look back and read over a few of your recent posts and realized how depressing you sound.

Anonymous said...

as soon as i saw Michael Johns voted off last week i knew it was gonna be a "teeny bopper lets vote for the cute boy competition".. unfortunatly David archuleta is going to win with his gaspy i sound like i have asma and need an inhaler voice... if america would know how to vote for tallent both brook and jason would be gone and david a. would be gone next week...

Anonymous said...

Jason Castro is the my favorite singer on the show. He sings right to my heart. On Tuesday, he had an off night. He was sick. He did not make excuses, but gave it what he could and took the bashing like a pro. He is still there because his fans absolutely love him. He is going to be in the finale (top 3) with the Davids.

Anonymous said...

Carly messed up the lyrics, true. It was not that noticeable. But why is Brooke still there?

Maybe the secret is that the singers need to have more weak performances. Kristy had some great final performances and *poof* she is gone. Carly, too. Look out David Cook, if you keep singing so well, it must mean you will disappear next!

Anonymous said...

Maybe, maybe not. She had her deal a few years ago and sold all of 400 records with a big time label. But there is no way that Jason should still be on the show.