Wednesday, March 12, 2008

David Hernandez goes home...seriously


So Ryan asks Randy if these three deserve to be in the bottom this week and Randy says it's tough because none of them were very good last night. He says it probably is the right bottom three. Paula says she's never seen a stronger bottom three and that it's difficult because they're all good, but yes, America got it right. Simon says he thinks America got it absolutely spot on.

So, Ryan says he can send one of them back to safety right now and that person is... Syesha. She's coming back next week. phew... I almost picked her last night to go home...

So, it's down to Kristy and David and after 29 million votes, Kristy Lee Cook is safe and David Hernandez goes home tonight. I'm in absolute shock right now... I mean, he should have next week or the week after... not tonight. Unbelievable.

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

absolutely the worst decision of this season. i thought the asia'h decision was horrible but this one was wrong

Anonymous said...

Kristy Lee is next.

Anonymous said...

SHOCKED TOO... Or actually, I was expecting something like this and can't feel but sad that there are SOO many people in this country still hanging from trees who judge someone for something as superficial as a job that is absolutely legal here... And if it were a sin, as much sins the performer as the clientele... And who hasn't been to a strip club ever, or hired an exotic dancer, bachelor or bachelorette parties, whatever... I feel sorry for David H. who was caught up in this media frenziness and it showed in his performance last night. I hope he gets over it and move it. His talent is amazing and he can have a great future if he plays it well... (although sadly enough, it may not be in this country...)

Tiffany said...

He didnt go home for the right reasons he went home for a scandal and the crazy thing is he was shocked too if you pay attention he looked at her like what the hell

Anonymous said...

Did you listen to him last night? He was awful. You can make up whatever excuses you want, but it was definitely warranted. There is no way that should be a shock to anyone, scandal or no scandal.

jaz300z said...

I am shocked that David is out tonight rather than Kristi Lee but I think the most shocking thing of the season is this premise that this is the best Top 12 of all time. That is just network hype. There is no one on this show that that reeks super stardom. Past years always kept me on the edge of my seat but there is no one that "does" it for me this year

b2b guy said...

I'm not surprised at all.

David has sick levels of talent and the ladies like him, but his song choices and stage presence were awful.

Danny Noriega looked like Harrison Ford up there in terms of manliness and the performances looked like they belonged on a cruise ship for late-middle-age women. I had not idea that he used to be a male stripper. Now that I do, I can see where he got the stage act.

That probably comes off meaner than intended and I think he has a real future but he needs someone to mentor his presence on-stage.

Anonymous said...

I have a feeling this is fixed. I think there's a disclaimer in the fine print of the credits that gives American Idol producers the final say. If you ask me, this is a case of, David Hernandez was in the bottom three, so the producers just cut him. Make a clean break early so that it doesn't get to the point where a stripper could be the American Idol. That would hurt the show's "sqeaky clean image." There's no way Kristy Lee Cook got more votes than he did. I feel bad for David Hernandez. He gets punished for one bad week, while Kristy Lee Cook hasn't had a good week yet. And, if we're talking based on one week, send David Archuleta home; he was the absolute worst this week. There's just no excuse for forgetting words.

Anonymous said...

My only thing about David H. is if he is trying to win over people's trust why not in your video of your last job just say you were a stripper. I think I would have had more respect for him if he did that then if he acted like it never happened.

Anonymous said...

Whoever voted for Krisy has to be deaf as a door knob. David was much b etter then she was. And who is voting for Amanda OMG she can't sing, all she does is scream

Anonymous said...

We can only hope that Kristy is the next to go

Anonymous said...

Thank you 7:55am. You took my own words. I did listen to him on tuesday, and it wasn't his best night, but he wasn't the worst. He's been consistently good in the past weeks. David A. who's had all the praise from everyone should have no excuse to forget lyrics; that is the most clear way for a singer to kill and disrespect a song (other aspects of a performance can be subjective). I can't imagine the overwhelming amount of pressure David H. must've gone through in the past few days from the media, from the public, and likely, from the production of the show... So, in instead they should have encouraged him and let him know that he should be proud of who he is because his talent is amazing, and that he could put it to good use now that he has the opportunity to do so... Of course they didn't; his one flawed performance is much more understandable...
I would respect him too if he had acknowledged the job publicly, but I understand perfectly if he didn't. Unfortunately in this country people don't forgive easily, and there are things that you do in your life, that even if they aren't wrong, they will always haunt you no matter what approach you take afterwards. Two of us would respect him, but most people would keep their very shallow standards and judge him... Sad sad sad but that's how it is in America, and sometimes we ourselves don't do much to help...

Anonymous said...

It is sad that we still live in a homo-phobic socitey. You all know that iff the scandle didn't come out, he would have NEVER been voted off. He may have not been the best...but he was far from the worst. Kristey Lee should have been sent home to ranch. You an hear about a dozen girls at every corner in Nashville that sound the same as her. She is nothing exciting.

PBX said...

I cant believe Kristy Lee is still around. She needs to be gone!

Anonymous said...

Totally agreed with this one! Predicted it the night he was trying to sing his last song!